Bethel Bakery loves to create cakes that will make your celebration unforgettable! We are the Pittsburgh area’s favorite decorated cake bakery.
We have round layer cakes that serve between 5 and 24 people, sheet cakes that serve between 16-72 people, and stacked sheet cakes that can serve up to 110 people. They’re iced with our Famous French Buttercream and you can choose from 14 different cake batters. For even more flavor, try one of our delicious fillings like chocolate fudge, peanut butter buttercream, or cookies and cream. (Optional icings and special fillings are available for an additional charge.)
Your Special Day—Bethel Bakery’s Cakes!
Try our hand-decorated cakes to make your next party, celebration, or birthday special. We offer many different delicious cakes:
- Itty Bittys. Little cakes with big style that are perfect for kids and first birthday cakes.
- No Cut Cakes. These cakes are actually made from 24 cupcakes that are places to look just like a decorated cake! They’re available in yellow, chocolate or half and half and can be decorated in dozens of ways, including a baby rattle, cat, diploma, and football.
- Decorated Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes—These cakes are even better than cookie. They’re delicious and are loaded with chocolate chips. They’re beautifully decorated and can serve between 8 and 18.
- Novelty Cakes. Are you looking for a special cake that will thrill your guests and tastes as good as it looks? Try one of our novelty cakes that look just like a dinosaur, Legos, or a purse! Match the theme of your party with a novelty cake. We have dozens to choose from and they’re great for kids and adults.
- Gender Reveal Cakes. Want to be surprised? We’ll tint our Famous French Buttercream filling pink or blue, and then you can find out if you’re having a boy or girl when you cut through your cake! Just bring in a sealed envelope from your doctor and we’ll take care of the rest.
- Picture Cakes. For an additional charge, we can scan a picture or logo on any size cake or cookie to personalize your party.
Cakes for Every Occasion
Bethel Bakery can design and decorate cakes to match your party’s theme! Take a look at our cake brochure to see all of the options and designs that we have. You can also visit our FAQ section for answers to many common questions.
If you have a customized cake in mind, please contact us and we will email or call you to discuss your order and/or supply a quote within 5 business days. Please note that custom cake orders need to be finalized one week before your event.
Click on the pictures below to view the designs and sizes that are available for online ordering. Please note that the price of the cake you choose includes the price for the decorations. Our standard cake designs are typically offered at no additional charge or may have a modest decoration charge included.
||Over the Hill
Our cakes are hand decorated. Cake designs may vary slightly depending on the personal technique of the cake decorator that customizes your cake. Size and shape of cake will also determine the amount of decoration on your cake. All of our cakes are shown to the customer for final approval when the cake is picked up.