A proud family-owned bakery for over 65 years

with a mission to prepare baked goods of exceptional quality that bring a special joy to life.

Click items in our digital brochure below to order! 

All orders for March 28th-30th must be placed, changed, or cancelled by March 23rd.

Planning a Wedding? Bethel Bakery can help!

Order & Pickup Options

Two ways to order your favorite baked goods:

  • Visit our online store. Be sure to place your order at least 72 hours in advance.
  • Call us at 412.835.6658 to speak with an Order Specialist to place or add on to your order at least 72 hours in advance.

*We do not take orders at our North Strabane location.

*Payment is required prior to your order pickup (at least 72 hours in advance) and recommended at the time of placement to guarantee your order.

*We do require a 48-hour notice for changes or cancellations on all existing orders.

*Custom requests may be subject to additional notice, up to 60 days in advance.

We're Hiring!

Lots of companies are hiring, but at Bethel Bakery, we want you to be a part of something SWEET! We thrive on teamwork; we work hard, and we have fun! We'd love to have you be part of our team! 

Looking for full-time, part-time, and seasonal help!

Bethel Bakery Now Hiring

Additional Information

Cookie and Dessert Packages

Click the icon to view our cookie and dessert packages!

Color Charts

Click the icon to view our color guide so we can bring your sweet ideas to life!

Cake Guide

Click the icon to view our cake guide,
and start building your dream cake today!

Sweet News

Let us share our monthly products, holiday features, order deadlines,
and a special treat for your birthday!

A Live Look at Bethel Bakery

Check out our Instagram page for the moments that WOW!

We’re so EGG-cited and we just can’t hide it! 🐰

Mini egg cakes are in stores today through March 30th only! 🤤

‼️Easter order deadline is March 23rd ‼️ All orders for pickup March 28th-30th must be placed changed or cancelled by Saturday, March 23rd!

Order online at the link in our bio!

#bethelbakery #bethelpark #bakerylife #bakery #pittsburgh #pittsburghbakery #shoplocal #food #Easter #creampies #pies #pieshop #dessertoftheday #EasterIdeas #eastersweets #egghunt
...

Eyes on the pies 😍

We have cream pies available to order for pickup on March 30th! 🥧

We have Lemon Meringue, Banana Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Coconut Cream, and Chocolate Cream! 🤤

‼️ Easter order deadline is Saturday, March 23rd ‼️ All orders for pickup March 28th-30th must be placed, changed, or cancelled by Saturday, March 23rd.

Order online at the link in our bio!

#bethelbakery #bethelpark #bakerylife #bakery #pittsburgh #pittsburghbakery #shoplocal #food #Easter #creampies #pies #pieshop #dessertoftheday #EasterIdeas #eastersweets
...

Happy St. Patrick`s Day! 🍀

We hope you enjoy all your Bethel Bakery goodies today! 🍪🧁🍰

#stpatricksday #dessertoftheday #Pittsburghbakery #bakery #bethelpark #pittsburgh #southhills #bethelbakery
...

Only ONE WEEK left to order for Easter!
🐰

Enjoy our delicious Cross Coffeecake on Easter
morning! ☀️✝️

Our Cross Coffeecake is our Danish dough shaped like
a cross with options of cinnamon, nut or apricot filling;
all baked with a streusel topping and drizzled with
fondant icing 😍

‼️ The Easter order deadline is Saturday, March 23rd ‼️

Click the link in our bio to order online!

#easter #eastersunday #coffeecake #icing #slowmotion #satisfyingvideos #entertainment #bethelbakery #pittsburgh #pghfood #bethelpark #canonsburg #fy #fyp
...